This proved to be labor intensive as the smaller baby worms would fall through the openings after each load of material was sifted and I would have to pick them out of the castings. Larger worms were not an issue and usually stayed on the wire mesh after which I could dump them into a 5 gallon bucket. This took me approximately 8 hours to finish using my sifter, and wheelbarrow as a catch all.
I was able to retrieve approximately 3 lbs of worms from both beds, which was good considering that we have had 100+ degree days and the soil in the beds was rather warm.
That being said, I made up two fresh beds using peat/sphagnum moss and newspaper, layering both several times. This built up media accounted for about 1/3 of the plastic tote. I came to find out that as a new bed the worms would try to leave; and out of one bed they did just that. I came back after 3 days only to discover that one of my beds was completely devoid of worms, they had crawled out. Lesson learned, shine a light on the opening of the bed 24/7 for several days to keep them in until the worms get used to the new environment. I also, lost about half of the worms out of the other bed, but I have enough to continue with my composting. I will probably build a larger outside bed next spring and purchase more worms.